{
  "report": "Program Busters",
  "release": 7,
  "ownedFinding": {
    "id": "PB-CARTRIDGE-001",
    "classification": "Pre-release privacy-related workflow defect",
    "status": "fixed-before-first-public-release",
    "applicationRelease": 50,
    "before": [
      "Lock synthetic A",
      "Select synthetic B",
      "Fail confirmation check",
      "Old output remained available; decryption confirmed A"
    ],
    "repair": [
      "Changed inputs clear output",
      "Changed inputs cancel unfinished work",
      "Worker results are bound to the active operation",
      "Output identifies its original filename locally"
    ],
    "browserEngines": [
      "Microsoft Edge",
      "Windows Playwright WebKit"
    ],
    "beforeCases": 2,
    "afterCases": 2,
    "realFilesUsed": false,
    "externalMessagesSent": 0,
    "productionUsersAffected": "Not established; reproduced in an unpublished candidate",
    "remoteExploit": "Not established"
  },
  "vendorAdvisories": [
    {
      "ids": [
        "CVE-2026-126885",
        "CVE-2026-126879"
      ],
      "source": "https://chromereleases.googleblog.com/2026/11/stable-channel-update-for-desktop_01744469280.html",
      "fixStatus": "vendor-patched",
      "advisoryDate": "2026-11-11"
    },
    {
      "ids": [
        "CVE-2026-124853",
        "CVE-2026-124854"
      ],
      "source": "https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/security/advisories/mfsa2026-125/",
      "fixStatus": "vendor-patched",
      "advisoryDate": "2026-11-10"
    },
    {
      "ids": [
        "CVE-2025-47934",
        "GHSA-8qff-qr5q-5pr8"
      ],
      "source": "https://github.com/openpgpjs/openpgpjs/security/advisories/GHSA-8qff-qr5q-5pr8",
      "fixStatus": "vendor-patched",
      "advisoryDate": "2025-05-19"
    }
  ],
  "openBoundaries": [
    "Same-origin/browser-profile access to manually saved unencrypted projects",
    "Public key labels do not verify people; distributed content cannot be recalled"
  ],
  "limits": [
    "Single tester and harness; no independent external replication",
    "No comprehensive native application, operating-system, dependency or real multi-user authorization audit",
    "Vendor vulnerabilities were not exploited or reproduced here",
    "Desktop emulation is not physical mobile-device evidence"
  ],
  "privateEvidence": "Exact source and runner hashes, original before/after receipts and package checks are retained separately. No private file or credential is included here.",
  "inboxFinding": {
    "id": "PB-INBOX-001",
    "status": "fixed-before-first-public-release",
    "classification": "Pre-release consent and delivery reliability defect",
    "observedDate": "2026-11-15",
    "originalObservation": "Cancellation of an unobserved operation returned 404; original failing regression retained privately.",
    "beforeReplay": {
      "method": "Original missing-operation rejection restored in an isolated candidate; ordered delayed-request replay",
      "initialState": "not-found",
      "cancelStatus": 404,
      "lateOriginalStatus": 201,
      "deliveredMessages": 1
    },
    "afterReplay": {
      "method": "Matching ordered replay against repaired source",
      "initialState": "not-found",
      "cancelStatus": 200,
      "lateOriginalStatus": 409,
      "deliveredMessages": 0
    },
    "repair": [
      "Persist cancellation even before acceptance",
      "Bind cancellations to sender and operation",
      "Check cancellation before insert and delivery",
      "Retry only the same operation; reconcile receipts"
    ],
    "realUsers": 0,
    "externalMessagesSent": 0,
    "limits": [
      "Synthetic authenticated identities, not real provider sign-ins",
      "Isolated SQLite adapter, not independent replication",
      "No remote exploit or affected production user established"
    ]
  },
  "messagePrivacy": {
    "id": "PB-INBOX-002",
    "classification": "Privacy upgrade, not a newly established remote exploit",
    "inboxVersion": 2,
    "newMessageStorage": "Client-signed ciphertext encrypted to sender and recipient",
    "legacyMessages": "Version 2 retained earlier plaintext. See legacyPrivacy for the version 3 protection upgrade.",
    "checks": [
      "both participants decrypt",
      "third key rejected",
      "signature and context binding",
      "plaintext absent from transport and persistent records",
      "lost-response reconciliation",
      "recovery and changed-key confirmation",
      "opened receipt after successful local decrypt"
    ],
    "limits": [
      "Synthetic identities on owned loopback Worker; not two real provider sign-ins",
      "Server still sees routing/account metadata",
      "No forward secrecy or compromised-device protection",
      "No retroactive privacy claim for older messages"
    ]
  },
  "legacyPrivacy": {
    "id": "PB-INBOX-003",
    "inboxVersion": 3,
    "classification": "Earlier-storage privacy upgrade; no remote exploit established",
    "method": "Server seals the exact existing legacy record with both participant public keys, no private keys",
    "atomicUpdate": [
      "ciphertext",
      "ciphertext-derived receipt hash",
      "immutable key context",
      "plaintext removal"
    ],
    "preserved": [
      "both participants",
      "original message text",
      "delivery/open/download receipts",
      "original cartridge ciphertext and key"
    ],
    "pending": [
      "missing participant key",
      "invalid or expired key pair; other ready rows continue"
    ],
    "limits": [
      "Not encrypted at original send time",
      "No original sender signature for archives",
      "No recall of previous access, downloads or historical provider backups",
      "Metadata remains visible; no forward secrecy"
    ],
    "browserChecks": [
      "Edge",
      "Windows Playwright WebKit"
    ],
    "realUsersTested": 0
  },
  "deploymentBoundary": {
    "id": "PB-CI-001",
    "classification": "Configuration hardening, not a demonstrated credential leak",
    "evidence": "/program-busters/ci-boundary-evidence.json",
    "limit": "Repository writers remain trusted; provider-enforced secret isolation was not configured"
  },
  "privacyCopy": {
    "id": "PB-UX-001",
    "classification": "Stale privacy description",
    "repair": "Distinguish external messaging handoff from the separate Suite inbox",
    "limit": "No unintended transfer established"
  },
  "temporaryAccess": {
    "id": "PB-OPS-001",
    "classification": "Owned deployment observation and verification gap; provider cause unresolved",
    "before": {
      "settingsRemovalReported": true,
      "sameVersionRepublished": true,
      "formerCredentialGetStatus": 200,
      "legacyRecords": 0
    },
    "repair": "Removed the temporary route from published application source",
    "after": {
      "formerCredentialGetStatus": 404,
      "anonymousGetStatus": 404,
      "anonymousPostStatus": 404,
      "engines": [
        "Microsoft Edge",
        "Windows Playwright WebKit"
      ]
    },
    "limits": [
      "No credential leak or unauthorized visitor established",
      "No wider provider vulnerability established",
      "No real message backfill was needed",
      "No customer content or credentials published"
    ],
    "recommendation": "Expire temporary credentials, remove their capability, and directly verify denial after deployment."
  },
  "dependencyReview": {
    "id": "PB-DEP-001",
    "classification": "Affected dependency presence; application exploit not established",
    "status": "patched-runtime-and-tooling-published",
    "evidence": "/program-busters/dependency-evidence.json",
    "limits": [
      "Vendor discovery is attributed; no new CVE claimed",
      "No exploitation or compromise established",
      "Selected component and artifact review, not a complete dependency audit"
    ]
  },
  "publicationBoundary": {
    "id": "PB-PUBLISH-001",
    "classification": "Public build input exposure; publication approval not established in this review",
    "status": "removed-from-public-artifact",
    "reportCount": 3,
    "uniqueSupportingAssets": 2,
    "before": "Anonymous extensionless URLs returned the three report documents",
    "preservation": "Original bytes retained outside deployment inputs in the verified private repository",
    "after": "Release guard checks absence from public inputs and exact preserved hashes; hosted removal is verified separately",
    "maliciousAccessEstablished": false,
    "previousCopiesRecalled": false,
    "personIdentitiesAndURLsPublished": false
  }
}
